- 1. In her essay “What Claim Does Girard Develop in This Essay?” Jane Bennet explores a question that is often asked about literary theorist Roland Barthes’s analysis of the work of French author and critic.
- 2. She asks what specific claim does Barthes develop in his essay on the author.
- 3. Bennet points out that Barthes presents several different claims in his analysis of the works of Proust, Flaubert, and Valéry, and that not all of them are equally relevant to this discussion.
FAQ
Why is Hamlet’s revenge dull?
There are a few reasons why Hamlet’s revenge is dull. First, Hamlet spends a lot of time pondering whether or not to go through with his revenge. He spends so much time thinking about it that he never actually does anything. He just sits around and talks to himself.
What is the something portentous that Gertrude’s birth metaphor refers to in line 195?
The “something portentous” that Gertrude’s birth metaphor refers to in line 195 of Hamlet is the fact that she was born around the time of the fall of Troy. This fact is significant because it foretells the fall of the Roman Empire.
What is the difference between Laertes and Hamlet?
There are many differences between Hamlet and Laertes. Hamlet is more introverted and private than Laertes, who is more extroverted and outspoken. Hamlet is also more melancholy than Laertes, who is more optimistic.
What claims does Girard develops in Hamlet’s dull revenge?
In Hamlet, Shakespeare explores the theme of revenge. According to Girard, the main character is driven by the desire to exact revenge on the wrongdoer. Hamlet is angry with Claudius for his mistreatment of his mother, Gertrude. Hamlet also feels betrayed by his uncle Claudius. He is deeply hurt by Ophelia’s death and feels it is his responsibility to avenge her death.
What does Hamlet’s last soliloquy mean?
The last soliloquy means that Hamlet is trying to work out his thoughts and feelings about what has happened. He is trying to come to terms with it, and he realizes that it is too late to regain what has been lost.
Which word best describes Laertes in Act IV?
In Act IV, Laertes is described as “anxious” and “impatient.” He is impatient to get revenge on Hamlet and to avenge his father’s murder. He also feels anxious about Hamlet’s ability to avenge his father.
Why is Ophelia so upset What does she tell her father Lines 85 112?
Ophelia is upset because she feels that her father is not listening to her and she wants him to change his mind about not letting her study medicine. She tells her father that she knows that if she were to become a doctor, she could help people and that it is her passion and she will not give up. She also tells him that she knows it is difficult for him to understand and that she loves him.
Why does Hamlet give his dying support to Fortinbras?
There are a few reasons why Hamlet gives his dying support to Fortinbras. Firstly, Fortinbras is the rightful heir to the throne, and Hamlet wants to see his country led by someone who is worthy of it. He also knows that Fortinbras will be a better leader than Claudius because he will be more aggressive and ambitious.
How Laertes is a foil to Hamlet?
There are a few ways in which Laertes is a foil to Hamlet. Hamlet is a young, inexperienced prince who relies on his father’s advice, while Laertes is an older, more experienced soldier who is more willing to take matters into his own hands. Additionally, Laertes is a much more ruthless character than Hamlet; he murders Polonius in cold blood, while Hamlet is more hesitant to commit murder.
What does Hamlet and Laertes have in common?
They both died in their youth.
Hamlet and Laertes are both characters in William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet. They both die in their youth, with Hamlet eventually following in his father’s footsteps.
How are Hamlet and Fortinbras similar and different?
Hamlet and Fortinbras are similar in that they both are kings who are struggling with their power and decide to take action. They are also different in that one is a prince and one is a general. Prince Hamlet is more noble than Fortinbras and has more political experience.
What is Girard tone toward Shakespeare and his play explain how his feelings are revealed through his language?
Girard argues that Shakespeare’s use of language reveals his inner world, and that this was done through both the way he used words and also by his use of metaphors. He argues that Shakespeare was heavily influenced by the French tradition of rhetoric, which emphasized the use of words to convey meaning. Girard claims that because of this, Shakespeare’s words often have hidden meanings beneath them. He uses this as an example of how Shakespeare’s metaphors are revealing, because when we hear someone say something like “heaven forbid” it can mean many different things.
What is the result of Claudius’s self appraisal when at prayer?
The result of Claudius’s self-appraisal when at prayer is that he believes that he is good. He trusts in his own goodness, and he trusts that God will help him continue to be good. He also believes that God will help him overcome any temptation that comes his way.
What are Hamlet’s last words?
Hamlet’s last words are “To be or not to be.” This is a quote from William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet. Hamlet is in a dilemma about whether or not to commit suicide. He questions whether to live or to die.
How is Fortinbras a foil to Hamlet?
Fortinbras is a foil to Hamlet in that he stands up to Hamlet’s authority and challenges his way of thinking. Fortinbras also stands out from other characters in the play because he is a foil to Hamlet.
What is Hamlet’s first soliloquy?
The first soliloquy of Hamlet is his “To be, or not to be” speech. This speech is one of the most famous speeches in literature, and it is a question that is asked by Hamlet. He asks himself if it’s better to live or to die.
Which best describes how the two adaptations of Hamlet differ?
The two adaptations of Hamlet differ in the way that they present the Shakespearean character. In the film, Hamlet is more of a hero, and in the novel, he is more of a victim.
What is Ophelia’s conflict?
Ophelia is a character in William Shakespeare’s play “Hamlet.” Her conflict is between her duties as a daughter and her love for her father, who has recently died. She struggles to decide whether or not to continue to serve as her father’s queen, or to pursue her own ambitions.